During the course of the investigation, new evidence was obtained from numerous interviews, several forensic interviews, and evidence obtained from the Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) lab. The investigation showed that Josie Spears had multiple physical sexual encounters with the juvenile victim. Based upon the results of the investigation, Spears will be charged with aggravated sexual assault with a child under age 13, aggravated sexual assault for repeated nonconsensual acts, two additional counts of lewd & lascivious conduct with a child, and a new violation conditions of release.
On 04-26-2017, Spears turned herself into the Vermont State Police-St. Albans Barracks and was then transported to Chittenden County Correctional Center. The Honorable Judge A. Gregory Rainville ordered Spears to be held without bail until her arraignment on 04-27-2017 for the new charges.